Filing Lawsuits in Chapter 11 -
A fairly standard type of adversary proceeding is a preference suit. These are authorized by Section 547 of the Bankruptcy Code. Under this section, if the DIP can show that a creditor obtained a transfer of money or other property in the 90-day period prior to the bankruptcy filing, that allowed that creditor to receive more than he would otherwise receive in a Chapter 7 case, then the transfer can be "avoided" or set aside, and the money recovered for the estate. In effect, the creditor who received the payment will have to disgorge the money he received, even if it was in payment of a legitimate debt. The goal of the preference law is to effectuate the ratable distribution of money to creditors. The preference period for relatives or insiders is one year.
Defenses To A Preference Suit
There are a number of defenses potentially available to the target of a preference suit. These are laid out in Section 547(c) of the Bankruptcy Code. The most common are:
A DIP can bring an action under Bankruptcy Code Section 548 to set aside fraudulent transfers of property made within 2 years prior to the filing of the case, and recover the property for the benefit of the estate. There are two types of such fraudulent transfers: "hard" and "soft". A hard fraudulent transfer is where the debtor transferred property to a third party with the actual intent to hinder, delay or defraud his creditors. A soft fraudulent transfer occurs when the debt made a transfer for which he received less than reasonably equivalent value. These include voluntary and involuntary transfers.
What are the "Strong-Arm Powers"?
Who Else Can File Lawsuits?
In more complicated cases, the creditors committee can take on the responsibility of pursuing preference or other claims. Thismight occur where the committee has requested that the DIP pursue such actions, and the DIP refuses to do so.
In some cases, there might exist claims against others for breach of contract, personal injury, breach of antitrust or securities law, or other specialized area. Under Section 327(e) of the Bankruptcy Code, the DIP can ask the court to appoint "special counsel" to represent him in pursuing such claims. After notice and a hearing, the court can approve the employment of such counsel on such terms as the court deems appropriate, including on a contingency-fee basis.
Pending Lawsuits Against the Debtor
Many times, there are one or more pending lawsuits involving the debtor at the time of the bankruptcy filing. The most common of these suits is a collection action by a creditor based on an unpaid debt. Lawsuits against the debtor are stayed (stopped) automatically, under the provisions of Section 362(a) of the Bankruptcy Code. In most of these situations, the creditor ultimately dismisses the lawsuit without prejudice, files his proof of claim, and otherwise participates in the Chapter 11 case.
Pending Lawsuits by the Debtor
In some instances, there may be a lawsuit by the debtor against a third party. The automatic stay does not stay these suits, since they are not actions against the debtor, but rather actions by the debtor. The DIP can elect to proceed with these suits in the existing forum, in which case the defendant is free to defend.
The DIP Can "Remove" a Lawsuit
Alternatively, the debtor can remove these
cases from state court into the bankruptcy
court, under the provisions of Bankruptcy Rule 9027. Once in the
bankruptcy court, they become adversary proceedings and are assigned
a new case number. Removal is automatic if done within a certain time
period (usually 90 days), and after that it is discretionary with
the court. In the removal notice, the debtor is required to state
whether the underlying matter is what is known as a "core"
or a "non-core" matter, and if non-core, whether the debtor
consents to the entry of final orders by the bankruptcy judge.
Lawsuits Can Be Remanded
If the defendant disagrees with this removal
to the bankruptcy court, he can file a motion to remand the proceedings
back to the original forum. The bankruptcy court will have the final
say on the matter. The court will take into account all of the facts
and circumstances of the case, including: whether the case is core
or not; the interests of judicial economy; the extent to which "forum-shopping"
is being engaged in by one of the parties; the status of the litigation;
the convenience of the witnesses and parties; and the burden on the
respective courts' calendars.
Written by Henry Rendler
Written by Henry Rendler
Discharge of Debts
Types of Bankruptcy
- Debtor in Possession
- The Examiner
- Chapter 11 Trustee
- Creditors Committee
- Filing Lawsuits
- Creditors' Rights
- Selling of Assets
- Reorganization Plan
- Plan Procedures
- Plan Provisions
- Common Plans
- Payment of Interest
- Chapter 11 Attorney
- Sitemap / Chapter 11
Life after Bankruptcy
US Bankruptcy Courts
341 Creditors Meeting
Find Attorney by State
Selecting an Attorney
Attorneys & Bankruptcy
What You Should Know